Butter Biscuits
Make firm, lightly browned butter biscuits from a stiff dough, with kneading and repeated beating before baking.
Prep
40 min
Cook
55 min
Prep + cook
95 min
Yield
About 40 small biscuits
Estimated timings. Includes extended beating, oven heating and two trays; add cooling time.
Ingredients
- 225 g butter, cold and diced, plus extra for trays
- 900 g plain flour, sifted, plus extra for the worktop
- 240 ml cold milk or water, plus small splashes only if necessary
- ½ teaspoon fine salt
Method
- 1
Heat oven to 160°C and grease two large baking sheets. Mix flour and salt, then cut or rub in the butter until small pieces remain throughout.
- 2
Add milk or water gradually and mix with a blunt knife into a very stiff dough. If it cannot be brought together, add liquid a tablespoon at a time.
- 3
Knead thoroughly on a lightly floured worktop until cohesive. Roll into a thick sheet and beat repeatedly with a rolling pin for 10–15 minutes, folding and turning the sheet between rounds.
- 4
Roll to about 1 cm thick and cut small rounds about 5 cm wide. Beat each round lightly on both sides and prick all over with a fork.
- 5
Arrange on the sheets and bake for 25–35 minutes until firm and light brown. Bake in batches if needed. Cool on a rack.
A firm biscuit dough
These biscuits have no yeast or baking powder. Their close texture comes from a stiff dough worked more heavily than a flaky scone. The small amount of liquid is deliberate: add only what lets the flour hold together, rather than turning it into a soft bread dough.
Beating is part of the method
Repeated beating and folding makes this heavy dough smoother and introduces small pockets of air. Use a sturdy worktop and keep the thickness consistent before cutting. Fork holes let steam escape, helping the rounds bake evenly instead of forming a large hollow blister.
Serve with something moist
Expect a firm, plain biscuit that suits butter, soup or gravy. Pair with chicken stock soup for dipping. If you want a softer no-yeast loaf with chemical lift, make damper. Cool the biscuits fully before closing them in a tin.